Koinonia Ventures Limited logo

Home - Corporate Profile - Our Services - Our Clientele - Management Profile - Contact Us - Resources - Links

Mainstreaming Services Into The National Export Plan
Reproduced with thanks to Trade in Services Section, 
International Trade Centre, Geneva

Question: What are business-to-business services?

Business-to-business services are services sold to other businesses rather than an individual consumer.  Business-to-business services are also known as "producer services" or "intermediate services."  Global demand for these services is expanding as companies outsource service support needs.

Question: What is a “traded service”?

A traded service is any service sold to a foreign national regardless of location, for example, management consulting services delivered electronically, or by other means (such as courier), to foreign customers/clients located abroad.  Other examples include tourism, educational, or medical services delivered in your country to foreign customers/clients visiting from abroad.  Banking services delivered abroad via branch or subsidiary established abroad are traded services.  Accounting services delivered via professionals to foreign customers/clients located abroad are traded services.  Instances of international trade in services can be found in almost all economies. 

Question: What size of firm exports services?

Service exporters may be any size, from a one person office to a large conglomerate.  In general, at least 60% of service firms have fewer than 10 employees and at least 95% of service firms have fewer than 50 employees. 

Question: How are services traded?

The General Agreement on Trade in Services (GATS) defines trade in services in four different ways or "modes" of supply. 

Mode 1 or "cross-border": the supply of a service from the territory of one member into the territory of any other member;

Mode 2 or "consumption abroad": the supply of the service in the territory of one member to the service consumer of any other member;

Mode 3 or "commercial presence": the supply of a service by a service supplier of one member, through commercial presence in the territory of any other member;

Mode 4 or "temporary movement": the supply of a service by a service supplier of one member, through presence of natural persons of a member in the territory of any other member.

The Four Modes of Supply
Under the General Agreement on Trade in Services  

Mode 1 or cross-border represents services that are sold by someone in your country to someone abroad, with only the service crossing the border – e.g., architectural drawings sent by courier, a consultant report sent by e-mail, etc.

Mode 3 or commercial presence refers to national firms established abroad selling services in a foreign market.

Mode 4 or temporary movement refers to services that are sold or delivered through the presence of the service provider temporarily in a foreign market.  For example, if you were to travel to South Africa to deliver a workshop, you would be exporting through Mode 4.

Question: Which business-to-business services do foreign clients frequently consume in the domestic market?

International organizations and foreign companies with local offices in the domestic market frequently consume support services such as: building cleaning, courier, equipment rental, equipment repair & maintenance, printing & photocopying, personnel supply, security services, and travel agency services.

Foreign companies or international organizations in the domestic market frequently consume professional services such as: accounting, engineering, legal, management consulting, and market research services.

Foreign companies or international organizations in the domestic market frequently consume support services for visiting business tourists and technical training services.

Question: How can service export markets be identified to indicate consumption of domestic services in mode 2?

Identifying the country of origin of tourists, students, and foreign investors will provide a list of service export markets.

Question: How can domestic firms with offices established abroad be identified to indicate national services trade in mode 3 or establishment?

The UN Conference on Trade and Development has a web site http://www.UNCTAD.org  that offers foreign direct investment country profiles that contain this information for some countries.

Asking the following questions will provide important information on services transactions by mode of supply as well as significant export markets.

Questions:

1.      What is the number of foreign students and what is their country of origin?

2.      What is the number of foreign tourists and what is their country of origin?

3.      What is the number of foreign investors and what is their country of origin?

4.      What is the number of foreign established firms with an office located in the country and what is their country of origin?

5.      What is the number of workers in the services sector including utilities; construction; transport, communication; wholesale, retail, hotels, restaurants; finance, insurance, real estate, business services; community, social, personal services; and public administration?

6.      What is the number of foreign patients and what is their country of origin?

Following is a collection of data sources to help determine services transactions by mode of supply.

Education

Reviewing the countries where students study abroad provides information on the scope of mode two or consumption abroad services transactions in foreign markets.

The Education at a Glance 2003 web site may be helpful in determining this information for your country http://www.oecd.org/dataoecd/51/51/14645901.xls

Review the Table C3.5. “Number of foreign students in tertiary education by country of origin” (2001) by OECD.  The Table provides information on countries where students are studying from Bangladesh, Djibouti, Ecuador, Indonesia, Kenya, Peru, Pakistan, and Rwanda.  The Table also provides information on the number of university students from OECD and Non-OECD countries that are studying abroad in OECD countries and in Argentina, Chile, India, Indonesia, Malaysia, the Philippines, the Russian Federation, Thailand, Tunisia, Uruguay.

Tourism

Reviewing the number of tourists and their respective countries of origin will provide information on the scope of mode 2 or consumption abroad services transactions.

The World Tourism Organization's Yearbook of Tourism Statistics provides information on over 190 countries and territories including detailed data on arrivals and nights (for the period 1996-2000) of international inbound tourism broken down by country of origin of visitors/tourists: arrivals at frontiers of tourists from abroad and arrivals at frontiers of visitors from abroad.  The Yearbook is offered online in the ITC library.

Foreign Direct Investment

Reviewing foreign direct investment on a sector specific basis by country of origin will provide information on the scope of mode 3 or commercial presence services transactions.

The following resources will be helpful in determining this information for foreign firms established in the domestic market and for domestic firms established abroad.

UNCTAD's World Investment Directory located at: http://www.unctad.org/Templates/Page.asp?intItemID=3198&lang=1

FDI Country Profiles contain extensive data on FDI flows and stocks activities of TNCs, the legal framework within each country/economy, including legislation relating to bilateral treaties that govern national investment policy.  The profiles include:

  1. FDI flows/stocks by type of investment
  2. FDI flows by type of industry
  3. FDI flows/stocks in the host economy by geographical origin/destination
  4. FDI flows/stocks abroad by geographical destination
  5. Number of foreign affiliates, their assets, wages, salaries sales, value added, profits, exports and imports
  6. Largest home based TNCs
  7. Largest foreign affiliates of domestic TNCs
  8. Largest domestic affiliates of foreign TNCs

Some of the countries under study are not covered (Pakistan, Djibouti, Mozambique).

FDI Interactive Database requires online registration, at no cost. This database provides information regarding global FDI flows, stocks, cross-border mergers and acquisitions, and investment treaties based on year and country.

UNCTAD's Investment Guide Series contain information on current foreign investors as well as investment opportunities, operating conditions, private-sector perceptions and a directory to sources of information on the country.

http://www.unctad.org/Templates/Page.asp?intItemID=2705&lang=1

Free downloads are available for Bangladesh and Mozambique.

Employment

Reviewing the number of workers in distinct service sectors will provide useful information on the distribution of employment across sectors.

The ILO Labour STA online statistics is a helpful source of information. http://laborsta.ilo.org/

See “Total employment by Economic activity category” under “Yearly Data”.

Health

Reviewing the number of foreign patients by country of origin will provide useful information on mode two or consumption abroad services transactions.

This information may only be available at the national level.

Professional Services

http://www.Martindale.com/XP/Martindale/home.XML

Provides a tool called the “Lawyer Locator” that enables users to search for a lawyer or law firm anywhere in the world. Listing of representative clients and office address provides information as to whether and where the firm is exporting its legal services.

International Organization for Standardization (ISO)

ISO Survey

Gives the latest available worldwide certification picture. It includes country-by-country breakdowns and comparisons with previous years. Free abridged version available from:

http://www.iso.org/iso/en/iso9000-14000/pdf/survey2003.pdf

NOTE: ISO develops and maintains the ISO 9000 standards, but it does not itself issue ISO 9000 certificates. Certificates are issued independently of ISO by the various national and international certification or registration bodies operating around the world. Each certification or registration body has a list of its clients, but there is no central database of all these certifications/registrations. The CD-ROM version (available for 47 FCH) of the ISO Survey includes a breakdown of certifications by business sector, i.e. enables to search for the number of certified service firms per country.

Investment Promotion Network (IPAnet)

Established in 1995 as part of the Multilateral Investment Guarantee Agency (MIGA's) mandate to enhance Foreign Direct Investment (FDI) in developing regions, the Investment Promotion Network (IPAnet) is the leading international investment-specific portal Web site providing free access to online foreign investment  http://www.ipanet.net/index.cfm.

Provides business information, legal information, market information, opportunities and events in the following sectors: information and communication technologies, energy and resources, infrastructure, manufacturing, services (financial, property, tourism/travel, transport/logistics, trade/commerce, and other services).

Trade Data & Development Indicators

http://devdata.worldbank.org/data-query/

Provides development indicators for every country from 1999 to 2003, organized in 5 themes: people, the environment, the economy, technology and infrastructure, trade and finance.

Additional Sources of Information:

The Central Statistical Office
The Central Bank
The Tourism Ministry
The National University
The Ministry of Commerce
The United Nations Statistical Office National Accounts Data

Service firms report that the following constraints may impede their ability to export.

Access to Appropriate Financing

Service firms require the ability to finance operating activities on the basis of an overdraft against accounts receivable.  Commercial banks may not offer this means of financing they may rely solely on physical collateral (despite the willingness of central banks to accept accounts receivable as collateral).

Access to Appropriate Skilled Workforce

The workforce may not have sufficient skills needed in service firms, for example, communication, problem solving, and computer skills, due to insufficient secondary and postsecondary education and training.

Tax Policy

Service firms may not enjoy the same tax incentives or treatment as other industries in the economy.

Access to Affordable Communication and Information Technology Equipment

Service firms rely on information and communication technology and equipment to operate.  High import duties raise the price of this equipment to service providers elevating their cost of doing business and impairing their ability to compete.  The Information Technology Agreement is designed to address this issue.

Competition from Government Agencies

Public entities providing similar services may compete directly with private sector service firms.

Monopoly Service Providers

Service suppliers reliant on particular infrastructure service inputs controlled by monopolies may have to pay monopoly prices for the inputs.

Public-sector Payment Practices to Service Firms

Excessive time lag of public-sector payment to domestic service suppliers, over 45 days, impairs cash flow and limits financial resources to develop export markets.

Public Sector Requirements for Hardcopy Documentation

Recognition of electronic documents would lower operating costs for service firms.  Service firms can increase their productivity by using electronic documents.

Poor Quality Telecommunications Infrastructure

Service providers are dependent on telecommunications infrastructure to conduct international trade.  High priced, low speed communications infrastructure can impair their ability to compete internationally.
 

Donor and Government Procurement Practices

Donor and government procurement rules and processes that favour foreign suppliers or other public-sector agencies may disadvantage domestic private sector service firms.  Open procurement processes that allow domestic service firms to compete for donor and government service contracts expose them to wider market demands and can strengthen their expertise and consequently their potential for exporting.

Knowledge of Service Quality Standards

National quality registrars may not be familiar with accreditation of service firms to international service quality standards.  Registration and implementation of service quality standards is critical to export competitiveness.
 

Monopolies or Exclusive Service Providers

Financial, telecommunications, transport, and energy monopolies that are not adequately regulated may artificially raise the cost of doing business and reduce competitiveness for service exporters.
 

Restrictions on the Form of Business

The inability of professional service providers to incorporate or function as multidisciplinary firms may reduce their export competitiveness.

 

© Copyright Koinonia Ventures Limited, 2006

 

Koinonia Ventures Limited logo